The Pioneer Woman website has done the research for us, the results are in, and this is not what we thought the most popular dessert pie for Thanksgiving in the Great State of Arkansas would be. Not at all. 

Did You Know:

The Top 5 most-searched-for pies are:

Top 5 pies - canva
Top 5 pies - canva

5. Pecan Pie
4. Key Lime Pie
3. Sweet Potato Pie
2. Pumpkin Pie
1. Apple Pie

That, my friends, is a very sensible list, if you were to ask almost anyone to name their favorite pie flavor, most folks would probably name one of those five pies...right? Not so fast there Pilgrim.

A new survey is just out from about the most favorite pies in each of the United States and the results are in, and Arkansas' favorite Thanksgiving Pie is not one of those listed above.

I'll give you a second to pick your jaw up off the floor.

So, I started running through the other pie candidates it could be, right?

Other pies - canva
Other pies - canva

Chocolate? Nope!

Coconut Cream? Nuh-uh!

Cherry Pie? Nah!

Banana Cream Pie? Wrong!

Frito Pie? That's not real pie!

Dang it, what could it be?

You ready for this?

The #1 Thanksgiving Pie in the Great State of Arkansas is ...

Peanut Butter Pie!

Arkansas #1 - Peanut Butter Pie - Canva
Arkansas #1 - Peanut Butter Pie - Canva


I don't think I've ever had a slice of Peanut Butter Pie, but I love pie and I love peanut butter so, we are destined to meet.

Happy Thanksgiving Y'all!

Now, check out Arkansas' Favorite Side Dish.

How to Properly Carve Your Turkey.

Texarkana Restaurants Open on Thanksgiving Day

Donations Needed for Local Shelter's Thanksgiving Day Meal 

Get our free mobile app

More From Power 95.9